RETURN!
I dont know about you but I work hard for my money, when I buy something I expect to get a quality product. If thats the last one to be found and its going to take awhile for replacement then I may reconsider. Another consideration is who is going to fix it? If you are paying a body guy then the amount of extra work needs to be considered against any cost associated with a return. I would expect the supplier to cover all return cost if the product came to you damaged but they may want you to cover the return shipping, which I would think may be expensive. Another option, they may offer a discount to you for a damaged part, again if that offsets the price for extra work then that would be fine with me as well.